In November 2020, a small landscaping company on the edge of Northeast Philadelphia became one of the most recognized business names in America. Five years on, Four Seasons Total Landscaping has 206 Google reviews and 273 different websites linking to it — more third-party authority than most local landscapers will ever build.
We ran our standard free Findability Score on them. Not because they asked, and not to pick on them — because they are the clearest example we have found of a problem we see in almost every local market. The report came back at 47%.
Here is what it found, and why it matters to any local business owner reading this.
A Business Everyone Knows, and Google Can’t Place
The scan checked 95 separate points across Philadelphia and recorded where the business ranked for “landscapers” at each one. On 85% of those points — 81 of 95 — it did not appear in the top 20 at all. It held the #1 spot on 2% of them.
That is not a reputation problem. The reviews are there. The links are there. The company is genuinely well known. The problem sits somewhere much smaller and much more fixable.
The Single Field That Explains Most of It
Four Seasons Total Landscaping’s Google Business Profile lists its primary category as General Contractor.
Every landscaper ranking around them on that grid — Kurt’s Complete Landscape, Farinella’s Lawn & Landscape, Bailey Landscape Services, Brother & Sister Landscaping — carries Landscaper as its primary category.
Primary category is the single heaviest signal Google uses to decide which businesses are even eligible to appear for a given local search. When someone in Philadelphia searches “landscapers near me,” a profile filed under General Contractor is being weighed against a category it never meant to compete in.
One dropdown. It is the most plausible single explanation for why a business with 206 reviews and 273 linking websites is missing from most of its own city’s map.
We measured the primary category only. There may well be other categories listed underneath it — but the primary is the one doing the heavy lifting.
Who Is Taking Those Calls Instead
We pulled the live Google results for “landscapers” in Philadelphia. The top two spots in the local pack both belong to LawnStarter — a national lead-resale platform, not a local crew — followed by EAS Landscaping. Four Seasons Total Landscaping does not appear anywhere in the top 20 of that local finder.
Underneath, the organic results are held by Thumbtack, Yelp, GreenPal and a Philadelphia Magazine directory page.
That search runs between 170 and 880 times a month depending on the season, at an advertising cost of $6.70 per click. Every one of those clicks currently lands somewhere that will sell the lead on — frequently to a competitor.
This is the part that should bother any owner reading it. The businesses winning that page are not better landscapers. They are better categorized.
Fame Is Not a Ranking Signal
The instinct most owners have is that recognition should carry them. It does not. Google’s local algorithm does not read press coverage or brand equity. It reads category, proximity, review activity, and whether your listings agree with each other across the web.
The Four Seasons report shows all four of those working against a company with plenty of the things that should count. Its newest review sampled by Google was dated 18 November 2025 — 302 days before the audit. Its rating sits at 4.4 while every landscaper ranking around it sits between 4.7 and 4.8. Of 19 directories checked, only 7 had a listing at all, and exactly one matched the Google profile on name, address, phone and website together.
None of those are hard to fix. All of them are being ignored because the business looks fine from the outside.
What to Check on Your Own Profile This Week
You do not need a report to run most of this. Open your Google Business Profile and work through it:
- Read your primary category out loud. Does it say the thing your customers actually type? If you are a landscaper, it should say Landscaper — not General Contractor, not Lawn Care Service, not whatever was selected the day the listing was created.
- Search your main service in your own city. Use an incognito window. If the local pack is full of national lead-resellers and directories, those are the competitors you are actually fighting.
- Check the date of your newest review. If it is more than a couple of months old, your review flow has stopped, whatever your total count says.
- Open your Yelp, Facebook and Bing listings. Confirm the name, address, phone and website match your Google profile exactly. Inconsistency across those sources quietly erodes the trust that decides map placement.
- Load your own homepage on your phone. Four Seasons’ homepage takes 13.5 seconds to show its main content on mobile, against 2.8 seconds on desktop — almost always oversized images being sent to phones.
The Part That Should Encourage You
Here is what the report found underneath the bad news: nobody is winning that Philadelphia map. Farinella’s and Bailey each hold #1 on just 3 of the 95 points. Kurt’s has the widest footprint at 20 top-20 appearances, and that is barely a fifth of the grid.
A fragmented map is the easiest kind to take. When no competitor has consolidated an area, the business that fixes its category, restarts its review flow and cleans up its listings can move across a lot of ground quickly.
Most local markets look exactly like this one. Being famous did not put Four Seasons Total Landscaping on the map. Being correctly categorized would.
See Where You Actually Stand
The report we ran on Four Seasons Total Landscaping is the same free Findability Score we run for any local business. It scans 95 points across your service area, checks your listings against your Google profile, tests your site’s speed and AI readiness, and names your three biggest gaps. It arrives by email in about fifteen minutes.
Get your Findability Score, or read more about how we approach Local SEO and Google Maps. If you want the background first, start with why your Google Business Profile is your real homepage and how the map pack actually works.
Frequently Asked Questions
Can changing my Google Business Profile category really affect my rankings that much?
Primary category is one of the strongest inputs Google uses to decide which businesses are eligible for a local search. A profile filed under the wrong primary category can be excluded from searches it should obviously win, regardless of reviews or website quality. It is also one of the fastest changes you can make.
How many categories should my Google Business Profile have?
One primary category that matches what customers search for, plus additional categories for genuine secondary services. The primary carries the most weight, so it should describe your core business as plainly as possible.
Why do national lead-generation sites outrank local businesses in the map pack?
Platforms like LawnStarter and Thumbtack operate profiles built specifically to rank for local service searches, and they do it at scale across thousands of markets. They are not better at the work. They are better at the signals Google reads. A correctly categorized local profile with consistent listings and current reviews competes with them directly.
Does having lots of Google reviews guarantee map pack placement?
No. Review volume is one signal among several, and it can be outweighed by category relevance and proximity. The Four Seasons report shows a business with more reviews than its three nearest competitors combined, ranking behind all of them across most of the map.
How old is too old for my most recent Google review?
There is no official threshold, but review recency signals to Google that a business is actively operating. If your newest review is several months old, your review flow has effectively stopped — and competitors collecting reviews weekly are sending a stronger signal than your total count is.
Is this report something you can run on my business?
Yes. The Findability Score is free for your first report and covers the same ground: a 95-point map scan of your service area, your listings, your competitors, your site’s speed and AI readiness, and three fixes you can make this week.